the meaning of ‘abstract’ and ‘concrete’ in hegel and marx

Dialectics of the Abstract the Concrete

The Definition of the Concrete in Marx ... Hegel’s Conception of the Concrete Marx’s View of the Development of Scientific Cognition Materialist Substantiation of Ascent from Abstract to Concrete in Marx Adam Smith, David Ricardo, Locke and Spinoza on Political Economy

get price

Hegel’s Conception of the Concrete - Marxists

Hegel’s Conception of the Concrete. As we know Hegel was the first to understand the development of knowledge as a historical process subject to laws that do not depend on men’s will and consciousness. He discovered the law of ascent from the abstract to the concrete as the law governing the entire course of development of knowledge.

get price

Ascent From the Abstract to the Concrete The Great ...

In order toestablish a foundation for such a method of investigation, Hegel worked out a new theoretical conception of the relationship between thecategories of abstract and concrete. Expounding the principle of the ascent from the abstract to the concrete, Hegel, in his characteristicpanlogistic spirit, ontologizes it.

get price

Hints - Marxists

For Hegel and for Marx, the contrast between abstract and concrete does NOT mean the contrast between ideal Rather ‘A concrete concept is the combination of many abstractions’. A concept, such as a number or a definition, is very abstract because it indicates just one of millions of aspects of a concrete thing, ignoring all other aspects.

get price

EREN CAN - METU

history—we can see here the influence of Hegel’s Logic on Marx’s methodology as well. In the third chapter, I attempt to indicate what the terms ‘concrete’ and ‘abstract’ mean in Marx’s philosophy. To define them I examine Marx’s usage of these terms in his different works –such as German Ideology, Grundrisse, Capital—and his

get price

Marx, Lenin and Trotsky on: Dialectics of the abstract and ...

'Marx applied Hegel's dialectics in its rational form to political economy,' he explained, adding that this was 'where to look for the true meaning, significance and role of Hegel's 'Logic'.'(12) There certainly was a 'non-rational' aspect to the fruits of Hegel's labours: but such an aspect had nothing at all to do with his dialectics, and ...

get price

dialectic - What is the "concrete universal" in Hegel and ...

The core argument of this article is that Adorno adopts the distinction between an abstract and a concrete universal from Hegel and criticizes Hegel, on that basis, as abstract. The first two parts of the article outline that both thinkers take the abstract universal to be the form of a false type of knowledge and society, and the concrete universal to be a positive aim.

get price

Andy Blunden Marxists Internet Archive - Academia

The classic text which defines the meaning of 'abstract' and 'concrete' for Marx and Hegel is the passage known as " The Method of Political Economy' in Marx's Grundrisse. Here we learn that: " The concrete is concrete because it is the concentration of many determinations, hence unity of the diverse.

get price

Ascent From the Abstract to the Concrete Article about ...

Expounding the principle of the ascent from the abstract to the concrete, Hegel, in his characteristic panlogistic spirit, ontologizes it. He transforms the principle into an independent entity, having its own existence—into the self-development and self-realization of the World Spirit, the Absolute Idea. K. Marx, overcoming the ontologism ...

get price

The Epistemology of Hegel an Underlying Approach to

formulation abstract – negative – concrete). That is, that an assertion is put forward, it is examined and problems found and ... presence online as they construct and co-construct meaning. 3.2. Hegel, Marx and Vygotsky Perhaps the most influential of the descendants of Hegel has been Marx. Marx made a number of revisions to Hegelian

get price

The Hegelian dialectic and Marx's 'Capital'

the human mind. This is the second trip from the abstract to the concrete. This is done in a series of Hegel's works and lectures, the concise version of which is Hegel's Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences. Here, Hegel's philosophical system is divided into three divisions: the Logic, the philosophy of Nature, and the philosophy of Spirit.

get price

Hegel/Marx Quiz Flashcards Quizlet

For Hegel, when the implicit ideal is made _____ (concrete) it always fails to match the real concrete situation and becomes _____, sowing the seeds of its own destruction by _____ those for whom the ideal was implicit; the _____ of a new ideal that subsumes the the previous antagonism is required for a _____.

get price

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel - Wikipedia

The triadic form that appears in many places in Hegel (e.g. being–nothingness–becoming, immediate–mediate–concrete and abstract–negative–concrete) is about this movement from inner contradiction to higher-level integration or unification. For Hegel, reason is "speculative" –

get price

Chris Arthur: Hegel and the French Revolution / Radical ...

Grasping the dialectic of revolution in only abstract form (‘absolute negativity’), and unable (for class-political and socio-historical reasons) to orientate to what Marx called ‘the class that holds the future in its hands’, Hegel resorts to an external unifier of opposites.

get price

Ascent From the Abstract to the Concrete The Great ...

In order toestablish a foundation for such a method of investigation, Hegel worked out a new theoretical conception of the relationship between thecategories of abstract and concrete. Expounding the principle of the ascent from the abstract to the concrete, Hegel, in

get price

(PDF) What does Marx think are the consequences of Hegel's ...

Marx shows that Hegel does not allow society to become the actually determining thing, because for that an actual subject is needed, and he has only an abstract, imaginary subject. BIBLIOGRAPHY: ABOULAFIA, Mitchell. (1978), Hegel’s Dialectic and Marx’s Manuscripts of 1844, Studies of Soviet Thought, 18.1, pp. 33-44.

get price

Mark Cowling: The Dialectic in Marx and Hegel an Outline.

that in Capital Marx “retained (from Hegel) the movement of thought passing from the abstract to the concrete’ (p. 130). In other words we should and should not begin from the concrete-real. (In what follows I shall use the term concrete-real to refer to the material world, the tangible, the kickable. I

get price

The Universal and the Particulars in Hegel’s and Marx’s ...

Marx in effect divided the level of abstraction of competition into two sublevels: an abstract sublevel that has to do with the distribution of surplus-value and a more concrete sublevel that has to

get price

Ascent From the Abstract to the Concrete Article about ...

Expounding the principle of the ascent from the abstract to the concrete, Hegel, in his characteristic panlogistic spirit, ontologizes it. He transforms the principle into an independent entity, having its own existence—into the self-development and self-realization of the World Spirit, the Absolute Idea. K. Marx, overcoming the ontologism ...

get price

Mark Cowling: The Dialectic in Marx and Hegel an Outline.

that in Capital Marx “retained (from Hegel) the movement of thought passing from the abstract to the concrete’ (p. 130). In other words we should and should not begin from the concrete-real. (In what follows I shall use the term concrete-real to refer to the material world, the tangible, the kickable. I

get price

The dialectics of the Abstract the Concrete in Marx’s ...

The dialectics of the Abstract the Concrete in Marx’s Capital Chapter 3 – Ascent from the Abstract to the Concrete On the Formulation of the Question In analysing the method of political economy, Marx advances a number of propositions of enormous philosophical import. These include the well-known

get price

The Universal and the Particulars in Hegel’s and Marx’s ...

Marx in effect divided the level of abstraction of competition into two sublevels: an abstract sublevel that has to do with the distribution of surplus-value and a more concrete sublevel that has to

get price

The abstract/concrete relation in the method of political ...

The abstract/concrete relation in the method of political economy. 1. Claus Magno Germer . 2. Introduction. Marx’s method is a topic of special relevance for the development of Marxist theory. I do not mean the overall relevance of the method as an essential moment

get price

Frank Ruda on Hegel and Marx - Bard College

Apr 30, 2012  Frank Ruda on Hegel and Marx – From Abstraction to Alienation to Universalism. By : Aurelia Cojocaru April 30, 2012 September 7, 2013. Frank Ruda. The BA2 Core Course for the spring term, on the topic of ‘Property’, co-taught by faculty members Catherine Toal and Michael Weinman, commenced on the 16th of April with two guest seminars from ...

get price

(PDF) What does Marx think are the consequences of Hegel's ...

Marx shows that Hegel does not allow society to become the actually determining thing, because for that an actual subject is needed, and he has only an abstract, imaginary subject. BIBLIOGRAPHY: ABOULAFIA, Mitchell. (1978), Hegel’s Dialectic and Marx’s Manuscripts of 1844, Studies of Soviet Thought, 18.1, pp. 33-44.

get price

The Logic of 'Capital': Some Recent Analyses

Hegel's Science of Logic (which is the meaning of the capitalization, bracket ... the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's 'Capital'4 marks a sort of turning ... Vazjulin's perception of the basic difference between Marx and Hegel is neatly mirrored in the following passage:

get price

Concept of Alienation in Hegel’s Social Philosophy ...

Jan 21, 2020  In this paper I made an attempt to discuss how the concept of alienation has been discussed in G.W.F. Hegel’s (1770–1831) social philosophy. In Hegel’s philosophy, alienation is part of the process of self-creativity and self-discovery. According to Hegel, initially our consciousness is alienated from itself. It cannot understand its own true nature.

get price

The Phenomenology of Spirit - Wikipedia

The Phenomenology of Spirit (German: Phänomenologie des Geistes) (1807) is Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel's most widely discussed philosophical work; its German title can be translated as either The Phenomenology of Spirit or The Phenomenology of Mind.Hegel described the work as an "exposition of the coming to be of knowledge". This is explicated through a necessary self-origination

get price

(PDF) Deleuze and the" Dialectic"(aka Marx and Hegel ...

Strategies, Vol. 15, No. 1, 2002 Deleuze and the “Dialectic” (a.k.a. Marx and Hegel) Gregg Lambert An old question has resurfaced in light of changes that have taken place in the concept of difference over the past 30 years, and I am thinking particularly of the changes effected by those works that Gilles Deleuze in Difference and Repetition de ned as belonging to “a generalized anti ...

get price

The Unknown Hegel The Russell Kirk Center

Nov 04, 2012  The Unknown Hegel. Nov 4, 2012. The Search for Historical Meaning: Hegel and the Postwar American Right. by Paul Edward Gottfried. Dekalb, Illinois: Northern Illinois University Press, 1986, Revised edition 2010. Paper, $24. F ew prominent postwar conservative thinkers have credited Hegelian concepts as a major influence on their own political ...

get price

Marx’s Dialectical Method - red texts

Dec 09, 2016  Marx was a philosopher. Marx created the philosophy of dialectical materialism (Or materialist dialectics, if you prefer), which consisted of the basic scientifically-verifiable laws of development of nature and human society. Marx’s dialectical materialism consisted of a set of formulas, laws, and axioms that were universally applicable.

get price

Ethical Politics Home Page

Ethicalpolitics is a domain managed by Andy Blunden since 2003. It contains Andy's home page and a number of archives of related information. Andy is a retired researcher with expertise in Hegel, Vygotsky and Marx.

get price